The value of an MBA degree is under intense scrutiny after a viral post on X (formerly Twitter) by a Chartered Accountant (CA) ignited a heated debate. The post warned that elite MBA degrees no longer guarantee high-paying jobs but instead leave graduates with massive student loans and financial stress. This debate has been amplified by leading news outlets like Business Today, India Today, Times Now, and Economic Times.

With MBA fees soaring to ₹25 lakh+ in India and over ₹70 lakh globally at institutions like Harvard and Stanford, students and professionals alike are questioning whether the return on investment (ROI) is still worth it. Are MBA grads struggling to find jobs? Is it still a safe bet for career growth? Let’s break down the controversy and analyze the facts.

The Viral CA’s Post That Started the Debate

A Chartered Accountant shared a post on X, highlighting concerns over MBA graduates who have taken out massive loans yet struggle to secure high-paying jobs. This post quickly gained traction, sparking debates among:

• Aspiring students considering an MBA.
• Current MBA students worried about job security.
• Alumni and professionals weighing in with their experiences.
• Recruiters and employers discussing hiring trends.

Media Coverage & Reactions

The discussion was soon picked up by major media outlets, with reports stating that even graduates from Harvard, Stanford, and Wharton are facing job placement struggles.

Rising Costs of MBA Programs

Tuition Fees at Top B-Schools

Additional Costs

Apart from tuition, students face expenses for accommodation, study materials, living costs, and opportunity costs. The financial burden is significantly higher for those who take student loans.

The Employment Crisis: Are MBAs Still Landing High-Paying Jobs?

Harvard MBA Job Struggles

A Wall Street Journal report revealed that 23% of Harvard MBAs remain jobless even three months after graduation. This trend has been seen in:

• Stanford and Wharton, where job placement rates have declined.
• Indian B-Schools (IIMs, ISB), where salary expectations often don’t match reality.

Indian MBA Market

• Increasing competition has led to stagnation in job offers.
• Some IIM grads are choosing startups, freelancing, or non-traditional careers due to lack of lucrative job opportunities.

Financial Burden & Loan Pressures

The Growing Student Loan Crisis

• Many students take loans of ₹20–40 lakh to fund their MBA.
• Without guaranteed job placements, repayment becomes a major financial burden.
• Interest rates on education loans range between 8–12%, further increasing the repayment burden.

Advice from Finance Experts & CAs

• Assess earning potential before committing to an MBA.
• Explore scholarships, employer sponsorships, or part-time MBAs.
• Consider alternative funding options like income-share agreements (ISAs).
• Be prepared for a longer ROI period than before.

5. Is an MBA Still Worth It? The Debate

Arguments in Favor

• Strong networking opportunities that open career doors.
• Higher salaries in specific industries (consulting, finance, product management).
• Skill enhancement for leadership and management roles.
• Long-term career growth and credibility.

Arguments Against

• Uncertain job market and ROI.
• Alternative career paths offering similar career growth at lower costs.
• The rise of specialized, skill-based learning programs.
• High debt pressure with longer repayment periods.

Alternative Career Paths: What Are the Other Options?

Skill-Based Certifications & Online Courses

For those hesitant about an MBA, certifications in high-demand fields can provide similar career growth at a fraction of the cost:

• Finance: CFA, CPA
• Project Management: PMP
• Technology & Data Science: AI/ML, Data Analytics
• Marketing & Business Strategy: Digital Marketing, Growth Hacking

Gaining Industry Experience Before an MBA

• Working in relevant fields before pursuing an MBA helps students make an informed decision about its necessity.
• Internships and corporate training programs offer exposure without the financial burden.

Entrepreneurship & Startups

• Some MBA grads prefer launching their own businesses over traditional corporate jobs.
• Startup incubators and accelerators provide mentorship and funding for new ventures.

Conclusion

• MBA costs are rising, but job security is declining.
• Assessing financial risks before enrolling is crucial.
• Alternative career paths might be more cost-effective in the long run.
• For those pursuing an MBA, careful selection of institution, specialization, and funding sources is key.

Instead of blindly following the “MBA route,” students should research their options carefully and make informed decisions based on industry trends.

💬 Do you think an MBA is still worth ₹25 lakh? Comment below!

📢 Confused about MBA admissions? Get expert guidance for FREE!